Saturday, May 5, 2012

Healthy GDP does not mean healthy people - A response to the Royal Social Report

Health advocates show their bellies with the words ‘‘Avoid a New Year’s paunch’’ painted on them. Thailand’s growing economy has given rise to increasing rates of child obesity and other health problems as people consume more fatty and salty fast foods


Bangkok Post. Published: 2/05/2012 at 11:21 AM - Newspaper section: News
Last week, when I first saw the BBC news headline, "Population and consumption key to future, report says," I thought, "Here we go again." And it has panned out just the way I thought it would.
For those who might have missed it, the headline refers to the report just released by the Royal Society as a contribution to the preparation of the United Nations Conference for Sustainable Development (RIO+20) to be convened in Rio de Janeiro next month. And when I took the first break from reading the report, entitled "People and Planet", freshly downloaded, I Googled the subject to see what others might have said about it. As I had expected, the fireworks had started and, with so many critics voicing their views, it was difficult to choose what to read.
Clearly, the issues relating to the number of people that can be sustained by resources of the planet remain searingly hot even over 200 years after Reverend Thomas Robert Malthus first published "An Essay on the Principle of Population" in 1798. I suspect that the controversies about what the Royal Society says in that report will continue to rage on well after the RIO+20 ends and this UN summit will be no different from most UN summits _ lots of talk and posturing will be aired but few, if any, substantive actions will follow.
Many critics say the report is poorly written and contains numerous inconsistencies as well as factual and logical errors. From there, blistering attacks on its contents and recommendations are launched. And as it has always been, this case is no different from that of the flat earth society _ no matter what evidence and arguments are brought forth, there will be people who continue to believe the contrary that the world can support any number of humans which, unless something truly catastrophic happens in the next few decades, may very well exceed the peak of 10 billion people the UN has projected. This is because new technologies will allow people to live increasingly longer and childless couples, single women and women who marry women to produce offspring with the services of sperm banks that are reported to be doing brisk business even in the present economic doldrums, according to Time magazine.
Although Thais are reported to be customers of those sperm banks, all trends indicate that Thailand's population will soon peak. When it comes to the need to limit their numbers, the Thais are much more willing to adjust their view than those who believe that the planet is flat and capable of supporting any size of population.

To read more:
http://www.bangkokpost.com/opinion/opinion/291373/healthy-gdp-does-not-mean-healthy-people
By Sawai Boonma has worked as a development economist for more than two decades.

No comments:

Post a Comment